Medical underwriting

Also called: underwriting, health questions, health screening

In short: Medical underwriting means an insurance company looks at your health before it sells you a policy. For Medigap, the company may ask about illnesses, treatments and medicines, and then say no, charge more, or delay coverage of a past problem. Federal law blocks this during your Medigap Open Enrollment Period and when you have a guaranteed issue right.

What it means

Underwriting is how an insurer judges risk. With medical underwriting, the company bases its decision on your health. In Medicare, you mostly meet it when you apply for a Medigap (Medicare Supplement Insurance) policy.

Medicare itself does not ask about your health when you sign up for Part A or Part B. Underwriting is a rule for the private Medigap policies you may buy on top.

Back to the page menu

How it works

When a Medigap company can use it. In most states, a company can use medical underwriting when you apply:

  • after your 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period has ended, and
  • you do not have a guaranteed issue right.

When it cannot. A company cannot turn you down or charge more for health reasons:

  • during your Medigap Open Enrollment Period, which starts the first month you are 65 or older and have Part B, or
  • when you have a guaranteed issue right, such as when a Medicare Advantage plan leaves your area or your job-based coverage ends.

What the company may do with the answers.

  • Decide whether to sell you a policy at all.
  • Decide what premium to charge.
  • Make you wait before it covers a condition you already have.

Limits on waiting periods. A wait for a past health problem (a "pre-existing condition") can last no more than 6 months. It can apply only to a problem that was treated or diagnosed in the 6 months before the policy starts. If you had at least 6 months of other health coverage in a row, with no break longer than 63 days, the company cannot make you wait. Less coverage can shorten the wait.

What it usually looks like. The application has health questions. They may ask about conditions such as heart disease, cancer, diabetes or recent hospital stays, and list your medicines.

State rules differ. Some states limit underwriting further, for example with extra open enrollment periods or extra guaranteed issue rights. Your state insurance department or SHIP can tell you your state's rules.

Answer honestly. Once you have a policy, the company cannot cancel it because your health changes. But it can cancel it if you were untruthful on the application.

Back to the page menu

An example

A woman is 72 and has had Original Medicare with no supplement. After a large hospital bill, she applies for a Medigap policy. She is past her open enrollment window and has no guaranteed issue right. The company asks about her health. She had a stroke two years ago. One company turns her down. Another accepts her but at a higher premium. Had she applied at 65, both would have had to accept her at their standard price.

Back to the page menu

Why it matters to you

  • The 6-month window at 65 is the safest time to buy. Missing it can make Medigap harder to get later.
  • Think ahead before leaving Medigap. If you drop a Medigap policy for a Medicare Advantage plan, getting a new policy later may involve underwriting, unless a trial right applies.
  • Do not cancel your current policy until a new company has approved you and you have the new policy.
  • Keep records of past coverage. Proof of earlier health coverage can shorten or remove a waiting period.
  • Free help: your SHIP at shiphelp.org or 877-839-2675.

Back to the page menu

Where you will see it

  • Health questions on a Medigap application.
  • Letters from a Medigap company accepting or denying you, or naming a higher rate.
  • Choosing a Medigap Policy (CMS Product No. 02110), Medicare's guide.
  • Medicare.gov's page on Medigap costs.

Back to the page menu

Back to the page menu

Check what you may qualify for

Sources

Page last reviewed: 2026-10-20 · Next check: 2027-01-05