Coverage determination
Also called: coverage decision, exception request, formulary exception, tiering exception, organization determination (Medicare Advantage)
In short: A coverage determination is your Medicare drug plan's official decision about a drug. You can ask for one when the plan will not pay, wants you to meet a rule first, or charges more than you expected. The plan must answer within 72 hours, or 24 hours if your health is at risk. If the answer is no, you can appeal.
What it means
When the pharmacy tells you "your plan won't cover this," that is not yet a formal decision. To get one, you, your representative or your doctor must ask the plan. The plan's written answer is the coverage determination. You need it before you can file an appeal.
Under federal rules, these are all coverage determinations:
- Refusing to pay for a drug you think should be covered
- Deciding whether you meet a rule such as prior authorization or step therapy
- Deciding on an exception request
- Deciding how much you must pay for a drug
In a Medicare Advantage plan, a decision about medical care (not Part D drugs) is called an "organization determination." It works in a similar way.
How it works
Who can ask. You, someone you name as your representative, or the doctor or other prescriber.
How to ask. Call the plan, write to it, or use the plan's form or Medicare's model "Coverage Determination Request" form. Some plans accept requests by phone.
Types of exceptions. An exception is a request to bend a plan rule for you. Each needs a supporting statement from your prescriber, by phone or in writing.
- Formulary exception: cover a drug that is not on the plan's formulary, or waive a rule such as prior authorization, step therapy or a quantity limit. The prescriber must say the covered drugs would not work as well for you or would harm you.
- Tiering exception: charge you the lower cost of a preferred tier for a drug on a higher tier. The prescriber must say the preferred drugs would not work as well or would harm you. Plans can refuse tiering exceptions for drugs on a specialty tier, and for moving a brand-name drug down to a tier that holds only generics.
Deadlines the plan must meet.
- Standard decision: within 72 hours. For an exception, the clock starts when the plan gets your prescriber's statement.
- Fast (expedited) decision: within 24 hours, if waiting could seriously harm your life, health or ability to regain function. A fast decision is not available if you already bought the drug.
- Paying you back for a drug you already bought: within 14 calendar days.
- If the plan misses its deadline, that counts as a "no." The plan must send your case to an independent review group within 24 hours.
How long an approval lasts. Once an exception is approved, the plan may not make you ask again for refills during the plan year, as long as your doctor keeps prescribing the drug and it stays safe for you. The plan may choose to continue it into the next year, but it does not have to.
If the answer is no. The denial letter explains how to ask for a redetermination, the first level of appeal. Follow the deadline printed on that letter. The plan must decide a standard drug appeal within 7 days, or 72 hours if fast.
An example
Luis takes a drug his plan moved to a higher tier this year. His copay jumped. His doctor calls the plan and says the cheaper drugs on the preferred tier caused side effects for Luis. The plan grants a tiering exception within 72 hours. Luis now pays the lower copay for the rest of the year.
Why it matters to you
- Ask for the formal decision. Leaving the pharmacy without the drug is not an appeal. Call the plan and say, "I want a coverage determination."
- Get your doctor involved early. Most exceptions depend on the prescriber's statement.
- Use "fast" when it is urgent. Say clearly if waiting could harm your health.
- Keep copies of every letter and note the date and time of each call.
- Ask for a temporary supply if you are new to the plan. Plans must cover a short supply in your first 90 days while you sort it out.
Where you will see it
- A pharmacy notice that says your drug is not covered and tells you how to ask for a coverage determination
- Your plan's coverage determination form, or Medicare's model form
- Your plan's decision letter, which must explain appeal rights
- Medicare's booklet "Medicare Appeals" (CMS Product No. 11525)
- 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227, TTY 1-877-486-2048), or your SHIP for free help
Related words
- Prior authorization
- Step therapy
- Formulary
- Drug tiers
- Medicare appeal (redetermination)
- Medicare Part D
- Appointment of representative
- Program guide: Medicare Part D
See also
- Prior authorization
- Step therapy
- Formulary
- Drug tiers
- Medicare appeal (redetermination)
- Medicare Part D
- Appointment of representative
- Medicare Part D (drug coverage)
Sources
- ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-423/subpart-M · checked 2026-10-20
- ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-423/subpart-M/section-423.578 · checked 2026-10-20
- cms.gov/medicare/appeals-grievances/prescription-drug/exceptions · checked 2026-10-20
- medicare.gov/publications/11525-medicare-appeals.pdf · checked 2026-10-20
Page last reviewed: 2026-10-20 · Next check: 2027-01-05